Arriving at justice by a process of elimination

Hans Kelsen and Leo Strauss

pp. 115-133

in: Hans Kelsen in America, Berlin, Springer, 2016

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to compare two authors: Hans Kelsen and Leo Strauss. More specifically, it will compare Kelsen's "What is Justice?"—his Farewell Lecture given at Berkeley in 1952—and Leo Strauss's Natural Right and History—one of the main works on political philosophy published in twentieth century America. Both are key texts dealing with the same subject, justice. Although the two texts were written around the same time by authors who shared a similar history (they both immigrated to the United States to escape Nazism), they seem to defend radically opposed points of view. However, despite and beyond their otherwise real differences, the two texts articulate the same important idea: if one wants to think about political issues, one has to address the question of justice. This chapter will attempt to illustrate through a comparison of these two texts the importance of addressing the question of justice, especially in our modern democracies.

Cited authors

Kelsen Hans

Strauss Léo