karl bühler digital

Home > Book Series > Edited Book > Contribution

Publication details

Publisher: Springer

Place: Berlin

Year: 2009

Pages: 47-61

Series: Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science

ISBN (Hardback): 9781402093371

Full citation:

Stefano Gattei, ""Why, and to what extent, may a false hypothesis yield the truth?"", in: Rethinking Popper, Berlin, Springer, 2009

"Why, and to what extent, may a false hypothesis yield the truth?"

Stefano Gattei

pp. 47-61

in: Zuzana Parusniková, Robert S. Cohen (eds), Rethinking Popper, Berlin, Springer, 2009

Abstract

Some of Kepler's works seem very different in character. His youthful Mysterium cosmographicum (1596) argues for heliocentrism on the basis of metaphysical, astronomical, astrological, numerological and architectonic principles. By contrast, Astronomia nova (1609) is far more tightly argued on the basis of only a few dynamical principles. In the eyes of many, such a contrast embodies a transition from Renaissance to early modern science. I suggest that Karl Popper's fallibilist and piecemeal approach, and especially his theory of errors, might prove extremely helpful in resolving such alleged tension. By abandoning the perspective of the inductivist philosophy of science, which is forced by its own standards to portray Kepler as a 'sleepwalker", I focus on the method he followed: he never hesitated to discuss his own intellectual journey, offering a rational reconstruction of the series of false starts, blind alleys and failures he encountered. The critical dialogue he managed to establish in private correspondence with fellow astronomers he later transplanted into his printed works, whose structure closely resembles that of a dialogue, however implicit.

Cited authors

Publication details

Publisher: Springer

Place: Berlin

Year: 2009

Pages: 47-61

Series: Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science

ISBN (Hardback): 9781402093371

Full citation:

Stefano Gattei, ""Why, and to what extent, may a false hypothesis yield the truth?"", in: Rethinking Popper, Berlin, Springer, 2009