karl bühler digital

Home > Journal > Journal Issue > Journal article

Publication details

Year: 1993

Pages: 77-94

Series: Synthese

Full citation:

Wolfgang Heydrich, "A reconception of meaning", Synthese 95 (1), 1993, pp. 77-94.

A reconception of meaning

Wolfgang Heydrich

pp. 77-94

in: Synthese 95 (1), 1993.

Abstract

Nelson Goodman's proposal for a reconception of meaning consists in replacing the absolute notion ofsameness of meaning by that oflikeness of meaning (with respect to pertinent contexts). According to this view, synonymy is a matter of degree (of interreplaceability) with identity of expression as a limiting case. Goodman's demonstration that no two expressions are exactly alike in meaning is shown to be unsuccessful. Although it does not make use of quotational contexts for the test of interreplaceability, it is tantamount to their acceptance. Goodman rejects quotational contexts; I argue that they should be accepted. This move offers two advantages.Firstly, and mainly, it allows interlinguistic comparison of meaning, something that has not been deemed possible in the received version of Goodman's account.Secondly, it restores the full scale of likeness of meaning damaged by the renunciation of those contexts that guarantee difference in meaning for diverse expressions.

Cited authors

Publication details

Year: 1993

Pages: 77-94

Series: Synthese

Full citation:

Wolfgang Heydrich, "A reconception of meaning", Synthese 95 (1), 1993, pp. 77-94.