Mechanisms and explanatory realization relations

Thomas W. Polger

pp. 193-212

in: Jacqueline A. Sullivan (ed), Realization, explanation and the mind-body relation, Synthese 177 (2), 2010.

Abstract

My topic is the confluence of two recently active philosophical research programs. One research program concerns the metaphysics of realization. The other research program concerns scientific explanation in terms of mechanisms. In this paper I introduce a distinction between descriptive and explanatory approaches to realization. I then use this distinction to argue that a well-known account of realization, due to Carl Gillett, is incompatible with a well-known account of mechanistic explanation, due to Peter Machamer, Lindley Darden, and Carl Craver (MDC, Philos Sci 57:1–25, 2000). This is surprising, not least of which because Gillett has cited MDC’s work as evidence that his account of realization is the right way to think about realization in the sciences.

Cited authors

Machamer Peter

Darden Lindley

Gillett Carl