Inconsistent boundaries

Zach Weber

A Cotnoir

pp. 1267-1294

in: Yacin Hamami, Floris Roelofson (eds), Logic of questions, Synthese 192 (5), 2015.

Abstract

Mereotopology is a theory of connected parts. The existence of boundaries, as parts of everyday objects, is basic to any such theory; but in classical mereotopology, there is a problem: if boundaries exist, then either distinct entities cannot be in contact, or else space is not topologically connected (Varzi in Noûs 31:26–58, 1997). In this paper we urge that this problem can be met with a paraconsistent mereotopology, and sketch the details of one such approach. The resulting theory focuses attention on the role of empty parts, in delivering a balanced and bounded metaphysics of naive space.